George Johnson’s recent piece in the New York Times demonstrates what’s wrong with status quo science and lazy science journalism.

Photo by Scott Beale

New York Times science writer George Johnson just published an article bemoaning science’s loss of credibility among folks like you and me. Near the top of George’s laments is that the “hard-won consensus of science” seems to be melting away. Before reminding George science’s purpose is to dissolve consensuses and follow the data wherever it leads, I’d suggest we take a look at some of the issues George worries about:

“On one front after another, the hard-won consensus of science is also expected to accommodate personal beliefs, religious or otherwise, about the safety of vaccines, G.M.O. crops, fluoridation or cellphone radio waves, along with the validity of global climate change.” — George Johnson, NYT

While I usually confine my dissent to science’s clueless mutterings on human consciousness, let me help George better understand why you, me and our neighbors have an increasing distrust of science in general, and New York Times science journalists in particular.

The “hard-won consensus” on vaccines ran into trouble with the over-the-top public flogging of Dr. Andrew Wakefield.  Most folks don’t like to see a well-trained, committed physician, who had the support of his patients, face a gauntlet of trumped-up allegations because he followed his hunch (which was latter proven correct) in order to treat children.  But the consensus really fell apart when the Center for Disease Control (CDC) admitted they lied about vaccine science:

“On August 27, 2014, William Thompson, a long-time researcher at the CDC, published a statement through his lawyer, Rick Morgan, admitting that he and colleagues at the CDC violated the protocol in a study on the MMR vaccine’s connection to autism.” — Jon Rappaport

The “hard-won consensus” on fluoridation can stay where it’s at. Fluoride has some benefits for your teeth, but is not so great for the rest of your body. If kids want to rinse their mouth out with this stuff they can, but why would anyone suggest we add this dangerous chemical to our drinking water in order to create a topical treatment for cavity prevention.

Two-thirds of Americans (versus 2% of Europeans) are subjected to fluoridated tap water. Why is George surprised I resent having to filter this stuff out of my water  just because some chemical sales rep talked a dopey scientist into saying it’s okay to dump this fertilizer byproduct into our water supply?

The “hard-won consensus” on global climate change (formally known as global warming), like fluoridation of water, is another example of how George is unable to disentangle science from PR scheming and corrupt-by-definition policy making. Global warming may be too big a topic to cover here (I tried here, but barely skimmed the surface), but it might be worth reminding George that: one, the consensus was never really a consensous; and two, no matter the eventual outcome, the debate has shown science at it’s worst.

What worries those of us weary of alarmist arm-waving is the thought of what might happen if George’s consensus builders were able to squash debate and allow corrupt policy makers to implement a worldwide scheme to regulate carbon usage. A scheme of this scale would not only lead to unprecedented corruption and coercion, but would almost certainly lead to state sponsored violence at a scale making missteps like the death of 1.7 million Iraqis from U.N sanctions seem trivial.

[easy-tweet tweet=”science is supposed to dissolve the ‘hard-won consensuses’ @byGeorgeJohnson is whining about” via=”no” usehashtags=”no”]

Even George’s  “hard-won consensus” on the non-existence of God is unraveling. Of course, God might not be the beard-wearing, cloud-sitting one atheistic-science-types like to rail against, but a double-slit-wave-function-collapsing, consciousness-is-fundamental-proclaiming one today’s scientists are discovering. None the less, materialistic science’s atheistic, biological-robot-in-a-meaningless-universe meme, is passe.

Then again, as George reminds us in the first line of his New York Times piece, he’s a science writer of a different age. A cherished time in the distant past when sanctioned truth passed from white-coat-wearing pillars of authority to the dutiful servants of truth at the New York Times.  It was a simpler time, when lazy thinkers didn’t have worry about the long-tail of pajama-clad truth seekers on the internet, and the pesky problems that come from following the data… wherever it leads.

Postscript: I’m sure George Johnson is a nice guy, and I’ve probably been too hard on him. I just interviewed his buddy, fellow science writer, and co-creator of, John Horgan… and we got along well. I’m sure I’d be friendlier with George once I got to know him… so here’s an invitation: George, join me on Skeptiko and tell listeners why your hand-picked truths are better than mine.

Alex Tsakiris is host of Skeptiko and internet show about the intersection of science, spirituality, and skepticism. He’s also the author of Why Science is Wrong… About Almost Everything. You can keep up with Alex on Facebook and Twitter: @skeptiko.


  • More From Skeptiko

    • Riz Virk, The Yoga Metaphor |599|

      Riz Virk, The Yoga Metaphor |599|

      Riz Virk… Yogananda… Autobiography of a Yogi… fact versus fiction… backdoor materialism? Riz Virk’s Website Click here for forum Discussion full show on Rumble: clips on YouTube: skeptiko-599-riz-virk [00:00:00] Alex Tsakiris: a show about what yoga is really all …
    • Julie Beischel, Love Beyond Death |598|

      Julie Beischel, Love Beyond Death |598|

      Dr. Julie Beischel… After death communication… Controlled medium experiments… How to talk to dead loved ones. Dr. Julie Beischel Website Click here for forum Discussion full show on Rumble: clips on YouTube: skeptiko-598-Julie-Beischel — 37.40 [00:00:00] Alex Tsakiris: a …
    • Robert Davis, Spiritual ET |597|

      Robert Davis, Spiritual ET |597|

      Dr. Robert Davis… spiritually transformative experiences… ET and NDE and DMT and Samadhi. Dr. Robert Davis Website Click here for forum Discussion full show on Rumble: clips on YouTube: [00:00:00] Alex Tsakiris: getting real about the big picture questions. [00:00:07] …
    • Marty Garza, Is ET Satanic? |596|

      Marty Garza, Is ET Satanic? |596|

      Marty Garza… UFO/ET… limited hangout disclosure… real disclosure… beyond the phenomenon… is ET Satanic… complicated. Marty Garza on Twitter Click here for forum Discussion full show on Rumble: clips on YouTube: skeptiko-596-marty-garza [00:00:00] Alex Tsakiris: um, this episode of …
    • Richard Grego, Materialist Soothing |595|

      Richard Grego, Materialist Soothing |595|

      Dr. Rich Grego… atheism / scientism rehash… Sam Harris… survival, the ultimate test for scientism. Click here for  Dr. Grego’s Website Click here for forum Discussion full show on Rumble: clips on YouTube: [00:00:00] Alex Tsakiris: , On this …
    • Al Borealis, Project Paperclip |594|

      Al Borealis, Project Paperclip |594|

      Al Borealis… Johnny Vedmore… Klaus Schwab… Nazis… Kissinger… Project Paperclip… anti-gravity. Click here for Forum Borealis Website Click here for forum Discussion full show on Rumble: clips on YouTube: [00:00:00] Alex Tsakiris: , On this episode of Skeptiko, A …
    • Eve Lorgen, Anomalous Trauma, MILAB |593|

      Eve Lorgen, Anomalous Trauma, MILAB |593|

      Eve Lorgen… anomalous trauma… complex trauma… anomalous love relationships… MILAB. Click here for Eve Lorgen’s Website Click here for forum Discussion [00:00:00] Alex Tsakiris: , On this episode of Skeptiko. A show about what happens when you really ask for …
    • Yvonne Kason, NDE Awakening |592|

      Yvonne Kason, NDE Awakening |592|

      Dr. Yvonne Kason… spiritual transformative experience… near-death experience science… medical science confirms. Click here for Dr. Yvonne Kason’s Website Click here for forum Discussion [00:00:00] Alex Tsakiris: on, this episode of Skeptiko, I keep asking the same question. Does your spiritually …
    • Vincent Tolman, NDE Lessons |591|

      Vincent Tolman, NDE Lessons |591|

      Vinney Tolman… dead for 1 hour… near-death experience lessons… be authentic… understand your purpose… love. Click here for Vincent Tolman’s Website Click here for forum Discussion [00:00:00] Alex Tsakiris: on, this episode of Skeptiko, A show about rules and …